Thomas Aquinas
Scholasticism / natural law · Medieval Europe, 1225–1274
The lens
The Thomistic lens reads an event by asking whether human law conforms to reason ordered toward the common good, the definition of law set out in the Summa Theologiae's Treatise on Law. Its vocabulary is the hierarchy of eternal, natural, human, and divine law; the precepts of natural law grounded in goods proper to human nature; and prudence as the virtue that applies principle to particular case. This lens asks whether a statute is an ordinance of reason promulgated for the common good or an act of will serving private advantage, since Aquinas holds that a law contrary to reason is a kind of violence rather than law. It distinguishes what human authority may rightly command from matters beyond its competence, and weighs whether resistance to an unjust enactment is warranted. From the account of the virtues it asks whether officials exercise practical wisdom or merely cunning. Where other lenses treat legality as settled by enactment, the Thomistic lens measures positive law against a natural standard and asks after the end it serves. It notices the gap between procedure and justice, and the difference between authority ordered to the good of all and power that has detached itself from reason.
Takes
No published takes yet.